Super Challenge #200 Look WHO The Cat Dragged In (Winners pg.5)

[Alltaken]

Ok guys, here are all the entries the top 50% of the entrants will move on to the next round for some big prizes, so vote well.

To vote (since the polls only go to 10 choices now) you will need to PM me "Alltaken" .

I will graph the results at the end and display them at the forum

List your three favorite images in the order of

1st
2nd
3rd

and then list up to 8 more people who you think should go to the second round.

Voting closes in a week. (i'll add links to larger images, and pre-post pro images later today, to see these now, visit the entry thread or http://battles.mudpuddle.co.nz/index...nails&album=13 )


Alphabetical order.

4Daniel



Amped



BackiZ



Bloodnut



Bogey



Canterian



Drachis



Duffator



ForTe



GrapeApe



MassTA



mfoxdogg



Modron



Mornstar



Radulan



RobertT



Sago



sgbzona



Slepnyrl



Vidar



Wu



Yogyog

[benstabler]

Well done all! (except for me for not reading Alltakens message, please delete this)

Edit: never mind, the others are putting their votes in this thread, so I'll follow suit:


1) GrapeApe <- Superb quality and expressions
2) Sago <- I'm noticing an @ndy feel in your materials?
3) Radulan <- Very epic feel, for such a short time period

8 Others who should go through
BackiZ is an amazing artist, but I don't think organics is his thing
Bogey spent a lot of time on the environment, but didn't get my vote because of lighting and composition
Duffator - hmm, not really sure what was going on there, but the materials are awesome
Modron could have spent more time on plot, but the quality of the cg is very good
RobertT awesome modelling as always, but please scale back on the chrome next time O.o
sgbonza would have come 4th place in my list- v. nice
Vidar - lighting could have used a bit of work, but that expression is great and the materials are top notch
Wu just because he distracts the opposition (oh, and his entry was actually quite good)

[Super Wu-Man]

are we allowed to post who we voted for here? if not let me know and i will edit my post......

hard decison, top three in no order yet.....
Robertt
Sago
Modron

other 8 in no order yet...
Slypnerl
Sgboza
bogey
Backiz
4daniel
vidar
yogyog
Wu (because he is so freaking awsome!!!!)

[Jacco]

here is my top three:

1. RobertT
2. Sago
3. Amped

cya.

[Job]

my top three:

1. Sago
2. RobertT
3. Modron

[Modron]

top three for me:

1) radulan

2) sago

3) wu

i'll update this post when i come up with the eight.

next 8 in no particular order:

amped
duffator
RobertT
Vidar
Forte
GrapeApe
Bogey
BackiZ

[GmL]

top three:

1) Sago
2) RobertT
3) Amped

[Laurifer]

1 Sago
2 RobertT
3 Radulan

You guys make it really tough to choose.

-Laurifer

[3Dean]

1. Sago
2. RobertT
3. sgbonza

[RANKN67]

1 sago *awsome models and great expresion*
2 robertT *looks complex*
3 wu *hilarious*

[henrymop]

1.BackiZ
2.Radulan
3.Yogyog


MassTA
Wu
Vidar
Sago
RobertT
Mornstar
Modron
Amped

[Modron]

btw, yog yogs image link is down for me, i was not able to judge it because i couldn't see it.

[me1]

1: Radulan
2:Sago
3:RobertT

8 More ppl(random order):
Amped
GrapeApe
MassTAsgbonza
Wu
Mornstar
Vldar
4Daniel
BackIZ

[The M.h.p.e.]

1. Sago
2. Mornstar
3. RobertT

And beyond them:
4. BackiZ
5. Modron


That'll be my list...
//The M.h.p.e.

[chimpoid]

1. Sago
2. Modron
3. sgbonza

I was kinda torn between sgbonza and slepnyrl for that last vote but sgbonza's cat was too cute to leave out of the running. Really nice work from everyone else and a lot of effort was obviously put in, but those three made me smile and that's worth a lot in my book.

[mfoxdogg]

1. RobertT
2. Sago
3. Modron

Other 8

BackiZ
Radulan
Drachis
Slepnyrl
Vidar
Duffator
4Daniel
sgbonza

[lucidMonkey]

Sago: Nice entry. That skin shader/lighting setup is tops. I won't say anything about the guy in the lower left if you share a textured sphere with that skin and a similiar lighting and render setup.

Robert: Seeing your images like this and the F1 on a monitor does not do them any justice. You get lost in the details You should print some of these out as posters so one could actually see all the insane detail you add.

Wu: you get my final vote just for all the effort you put in... painting and scanning, you crazy fool. (not to mention all the hype)

[Radulan]

since for a strange reason I refuse to vote for myself.


Sago: excellent expression... Good example of simple yet true.
RobertT : Ambitious, Great textures, lots of work was put in there.
Backiz: Nice pun, and well executed.

and the 8 others (Mainly chosen because I'm curious what they would make.)
Amped: enjoyable, yet not eye catching...
4Daniel: Personally I love the mask... simple but adequate composition.
GrapeApe: Nice attempt at a photo that might actually be taken.. on another world.
MassTA: Very well done hair and realistic, yet the composition is flat.
Modron: very high detail textures, and good modeling, yet the pose...
Wu: Textures are very nice, the background is realistic, but your modeling and composition need improvement.
yogyog: very good tortured bird, composition could be better.
Forte: Gotta love the phylum Mollusca.

[forTe]

My Top Three (in no particular order):
Sgbonza
Sago
RobertT

Other nominations (in no particular order):
forTe (because I'm just that humble)
Wu
Vidar
Radulan
Mornstar
Modron
GrapeApe
Backiz

Some really tough decisions, all the entries are well made and put together!

[Grape Ape]

Top Three

Slepnyrl
RobertT
Sago

The others, no order.

BackiZ
Modron
sgbonza