you probably set the IPO before making them single user, so the alpha ipo was copied each time. to solve, go to the materials you DONT want animated, in your IPO window select Material mode, and select all the keys there and X them into oblivion.
Unfortunately no, I select each material and the IPO stays the same; select WELD (material) change IPO, select WELD.001 Change IPO - the IPO of WELD is also changed :S