EDIT:
ok i took the 1 suggestions and made the top ever so slightly shinier and plus i blured the envmap a bit which make it look a little more “real” i’m pleased with the result and tempted to call it finished might do a bottle later but got loads of work to do so …
enough! here it is
PLEASE CRIT !!!
ok yes i know i never finish anything> but never mind hay
which one do you like better?
i prefer the second one
Between the two? I’ll go for the second. However, I prefer the top on the first one…
this was mainly a modeling exersise so any critin that area would be greatly apreisated. i might do a bottle as well and try to learn to fake refraction.
Nice, but the second it my favorit ;))
bottom, the top is too dark
i know its nothing compared to a millenium falcon 
but all crits welcome!