Buying a new workstation, AMD or Nvidia?

Hello guys, in the past it seems Nvidia have been the go-to cards to get for workstations. I wonder if this is still true these days?

I am looking at getting something performing similar to a 1070, but I wonder how essential Nvidia is for this?

I am not doing GPU-rendering that much. I mostly work in game engines, and the occasional CPU-render in Blender.

To clarify, the computer will mainly be a workstation, sometimes games. So I need good performance in Blender, video-editing software, Krita/Gimp, 3D Coat, Substance Painter and game engines.

I am asking mainly because of concerns with Nvidia drivers lately (Had so many issues with them in the past), and AMD seem to be on a stable roll.

Whilst I am asking about GPUs I might as well ask about AMD CPUs compared to Intel, if you have any insight on that I would like to know :slight_smile:

Thanks!

Best regards
//Morgan

Edit:


This is the build I have in mind at the moment.

Intel CPUs are currently still much faster than AMD. I have always loved Nvidia video cards and don’t have any issues. Make sure you get the i7 6700K which is a little better than the 6700, as it allows overclocking, etc.

Oh, I missed that it wasn’t that much more expensive, will go ahead and update with that CPU then :slight_smile:

So now it only stands adding a CPU cooler and figuring out which GPU I should go for, if a 1070 is worth the extra cost over a AMD 480 or 1060.

It depends on what OS you will use. Certainly on Linux, NVidia is less trouble and CUDA beats OpenCL hands down.

If you dont plan on overclocking just get the normal 6700 not the k. overclocking is not for everyone :wink:

as for gpu… right now the cuda implementation of cycles is far more complete then the opencl version, this may change over the next year but its better to buy for now rather then to buy for the future. this means get a NVIDIA card over a AMD card. (CUDA is nvidia only)

Thanks for the help guys!

Ended up with the following rig:


Black Friday sales for the win!

Little bit concerned about only 16gb RAM, but it if limits me I’ll just buy some more :slight_smile:

Hey, nice rig, may you think about to add a SSD for system and main software.
They speed up the whole system so nicely, startup system/applications, copy files, system maintenance and so forth.
256 GB should be fine for a Windows system and not to expensive today.

Cheers, mib

With the ram make sure to buy the exact same kit you got to begin with when you upgrade. You may encounter issues, sometimes RAM can be a bit screwy with matching two kits etc etc.

Yes, aware of that :slight_smile: Thanks