Robertt is the best for me but it doesnt relate too well with the topic which is Giger’s Alien, so I voted Penitentmen. IMHO not a good topic, too specific.
Hard decision but i had to go with Robertt he captured Giger’s brilliance
the other entries were good. Hogies was most straight forward execpt the background was too wild and took away from the alien
Cool entries once again
one thing bugs me though. Hos’ entry looks like open to me since he used the same character as in his previous entry.
I guess an open entry can’t get any votes or that wouldn’t make any sense to name it open. Then again, maybe I missed something.
Anyways I’ll keep my vote untill someone makes this more clear to me.
If Hos doesn’t get my vote, I’ll have to make my mind between RobertT (I’m tired to vote for you, man ;)) and penitentman.
Cheers.
-IS-
[edit]btw: I know this isn’t the wc118 my mistake hehe. And thanks raseri for your vote[/edit]
Yep, total reuse… I didn’t read the rules before entering, but you’re
right: this should have been flagged as ‘open’.
As far as I can tell from the rules, ‘open’ vs ‘pure’ is only an issue in
case of a tie, the relevant paragraph quoted below:
At the end of two days of voting, the entry with the highest number of votes wins. In the event of a tie, a Pure entry will win over an Open entry. In the event of a tie between Pure or Open entries, the earliest submitted entry will win - the submission time is taken as the last edited time of the submission message, or the message creation time if it hasn’t been edited.
Igor’s was funny too 