Challenge #1217 "The things you find up in the old attic…" Voting CLOSED

This week’s theme: The things you find up in the old attic…

Which entry would you like to see win?
(If you cannot decide, pick up to 3.)

  • Khamurai (A thing you don’t want to find in an old attic)
  • Jean-Luc (Accursed Tin Toy)
  • codecontemplator (The Dor Beetle in the Attic)
  • 3dnotguru (woodenhorserender)
  • Almond780 (The things you find up in the old attic […])
  • kosmoiko (Peekaboo)
  • Boder (After finishing my career, I finally got up the […])
  • Frau_Kwatsch (sleeping beautys nightmare)
  • I_drink_water (Found my ladder! )
  • sidp (Saved for Later)
  • fcharr (Memories)
  • Monoceros_Studios (Forgotten Childhood)
  • TazDevyl (Sweeney Todd-esque)
0 voters

After 2 days of voting, a winner is declared: The voting will close on: Wed, Oct 21, 2026 11:00 PM.
The winner picks the theme for next week.

If the winner doesn’t supply a theme before Thursday 22:30 GMT, the organizer will select the theme. In this case, the winner’s theme will be used the next time we are lacking a theme on Thursday 22:30 GMT. :slight_smile:

Having selected the theme, the winner will not be eligible to enter that week. They may however still submit an image, but it won’t be included in the voting.

This week’s winner:
winner_1217

Next Challenge:
theme_1218

Pure Entries

• Khamurai: A thing you don’t want to find in an old attic



• Jean-Luc: Accursed Tin Toy



• codecontemplator: The Dor Beetle in the Attic



• 3dnotguru: woodenhorserender



• Almond780: The things you find up in the old attic… are the things that have been forgotten.



• kosmoiko: Peekaboo



• Boder: After finishing my career, I finally got up the nerve to ask my PA Suzanne where she kept them… those godawful things I never wanted to think about again.



• Frau_Kwatsch: sleeping beautys nightmare



• I_drink_water: Found my ladder!



• sidp: Saved for Later



Open Entries

• fcharr: Memories


(Everything is taken from previous works, with the exception of the wood that makes up the floor and roof beams of the attic. The material for those, however, was taken from a previous entry, and modified to better suit the lighting and camera positioning.)



• Monoceros_Studios: Forgotten Childhood


(the rocking horse was originally intended for the ‘Wooden Toys’ challenge a while back!)



• TazDevyl: Sweeney Todd-esque



Non-competing Entries

• NeilJamesFrarey: Holy Bible, priest’s tab collar and a hand gun.



• Helge: Attic Attack!



2 Likes

I know that voting is not yet over. So this is not a please vote for me reply.

But more a learning moment for me and probably for others. As for what the voters prioritize.

So to show my point, I will give a direct comparison of my render(Almond780: The things you find up in the old attic… are the things that have been forgotten.) and the lead’s(sidp: Saved for Later) render.

  • Summary:

    1. My render is more of a joke of where the deleted objects go.
    2. Sidp’s render is implying that you still have that Christmas tree in your attic because there is no reason to buy another one. But im not sidp, so IDK the true intention.
  • Language:

    1. My render needed for you to understand English and use Blender long enough to get the joke.
    2. sidp’s render doesn’t need any language except for you to understand what Christmas is. So anyone can understand even for a person that hasn’t touched Blender in there life.
  • Composition:

    1. My render is quite messy. Yes the “Delete selected objects?” ui is the hero. But you are also expected to read the file names(as in untitled.blend, cube.001 and ect), to get the joke.
    2. While sidp’s render is just a god ray on to the Christmas tree. That’s it. You don’t need to look at the cardboard boxes or the broken floor or even the paint bucket to understand it.

Also you could say “this Contest was a photo-realism contest.” But as for 3dnotguru’s render (woodenhorserender) is the most photo realistic. And has 2 votes vs 10, as for right now.

Overall this just shows what is actually can be voted in these Contests. Also this comparison could be the same for all renders in this Contest. But they will have 1 or more points that is against the leads render, but not have all of them.

I hope this useful for someone and for have an understanding of what to keep in mind for these Contests.

1 Like

Take your sour grapes somewhere else, please. This is embarrassing for you and not in the friendly spirit of the weekend challenge

1 Like

Yea im probably keep climbing the first hill without realizing it.

Actually, I didn’t take your original post as a complaint, but rather as an analysis of why certain images do better in the voting. I think you identified some important aspects that work really good in @sidp’s entry. (And agree with it ranking good so far. (?))

A few years back, I compiled a list of things that seem to work well in the Weekend Challenge voting. And much of it isn’t even technical:

One thing I want to add: “Tell a story! (And make it easy to read.)” A good story or even humor will always attract some additional votes - even if the entry may not be the best on a technical level.

9 Likes

No need to be that harsh with yourself or you might see it this way.. you are already in the valley… :winking_face_with_tongue:

Seriously.. there is a reason why fun was mentioned first..

..and “the glory” is maybe more something to “simply get the next topic”.. :grinning_cat_with_smiling_eyes:

So.. even if only participating once and also for some “special event”..

Thanks @Helge to do this every week..

4 Likes

That is pure STRESS - for me, at least :slight_smile: It’s always a case of: “Oh - first place! I need a topic, a topic! A TOPIC!!!”… and my wife usually just steers clear of me for a while :winking_face_with_tongue:

@Almond780 I would also like to reply to you, but I’ll wait until after the voting.

3 Likes

In your own movie, you’re always the good guy. Who would have thought that in real life, I’d be the cop who rings the doorbell late at night on a rainy evening and says with a sad, serious expression, “Are you mali_zweipunktnull? I’m afraid I have some bad news. You’ve won!” :wink:

7 Likes

This is very interesting. I love that summary, agree a lot and will definetly try the eys :eyes:
One thing to add from my side: sometimes the community also rewards technically cool solutions, like fancy shaders.

3 Likes

Insanely valuable comment :100:

2 Likes

Definitely! In general, making the entry unique / stand out in one way or another is usually a good idea. And there are so many ways to do that. It can be a technical aspect, a surprising idea, a unique choice of colors, etc.)
That is probably true for many types of competitions. Especially when there are more entries than in our little challenge. :slight_smile:

2 Likes

That is why I ALWAYS think of a topic (even knowing I may not win) JUST IN CASE. That being said, I have 2 in my head that I’m sure that by the time I win, I will forget what they were.

3 Likes

You know, I don’t enter the weekend challenge looking to win it, I do it for fun! Some of the topics have really inspired me, they gave me ideas for animations. Usually, my goals are too lofty to pull off within the allotted time. Sometimes my vision of what I want is so good that I’ll keep working on my entry well past the deadline because I want to create that vision in my head.

The Weekend Challenge should be all about fun, creating art, sharing it with each other, and having a good time. Who cares who wins?

What does winning a Weekend Challenge give you? Yes you won. Yes your art is in the top row. Very good things! Are you going to ad a win in the Weekend Challenge to your resume/CV? Will it result in a promotion at work?

Just enjoy it and have fun!

Randy

3 Likes

And… the winner of Weekend Challenge 1217 with votes from 51.6% of the voters is… sidp!
Here’s to all the great participators…


Saved for Later

4 Likes

Woah that is a lot, all I can say is thank you everyone.

For my thoughts on these points here.

“Actually, I didn’t take your original post as a complaint, but rather as an analysis” That was the intention. I was not trying to be disrespectful or arrogant or even be a sore loser. To be honest with im not really a 3D artist. But that does not mean im not to going be one. But really im more of a technical artist than a 3D one. I think in way where how I can break down things and understand how to improve. Just I don’t express greatly on both sides without hurting someone. But for “Tell a story! (And make it easy to read.)” yea I will definitely keep that in mind.

“No need to be that harsh with yourself or you might see it this way.. you are already in the valley… :winking_face_with_tongue:” Haha, yea that graph probably shows where I am in social and artistic maturity here. But there is always time to improve from that.

" That is pure STRESS - for me, at least :slight_smile: It’s always a case of: “Oh - first place! I need a topic, a topic! A TOPIC!!!”… and my wife usually just steers clear of me for a while :winking_face_with_tongue:" Really? I can think a lot of an ideas. For example: Lets say the theme is the “default cube” Many people can do a lot with that.

“What does winning a Weekend Challenge give you?” To me its knowing that if im on the right track in the eyes of other blender artist. But of course I don’t need stress about that.

2 Likes

Congrats @sidp and @Jean-Luc for the big votes :slight_smile:

Quite chatty for a voting post. My reasons for participating is that it’s like having a job. After roughly 10 years of challenges, I am a bit of a professional artist myself :wink: Every entry I make gets added to my site as well as twitter, blue sky, deviant art, and of course FB. I see it as long term SEO, maybe my site can start making money again :smiling_face_with_sunglasses:

4 Likes

And they did! 48 entries in 2017!
Unfortunately, those images got lost when Blenderartists moved to Discourse.


Finding a unique topic, that works well, can be challenging after 1217 winners have thought about the same thing before. But of course, there are still a lot of themes left. :wink:

4 Likes

Yep, an excellent win. If you magnify it, you can see all sorts of little things that made it even better :slight_smile: I also think that all of the entries were excellent too, such a lot of great concepts.

I keep entering to stretch myself, try to learn new things and new ways of working with Blender :slight_smile:

4 Likes

That’s fantastic, I’m so happy! My favorite entry this weekend was definitely @Jean-Luc’s. It’s a beautiful render.

@Helge knocked on the door to give me the bad news last night and I’m still processing. New theme coming up!

8 Likes