I’m not directing this at anyone in particular, but don’t you guys think it’s kind of retarded to base your C&C on the person’s postcount before you even look at the picture?
No, it’s kind and respectfull to do that. Ok, let’s say I’m not even looking at the person who did it. I would have said “This sux”, and that’s all, since I wouldn’t consider that he is a fellow blenderhead, a 3d art hobbyist, or something, so I wouldn’t like to help him.
It’s kind, because the first posts usualy are not that great in quality, so when you see that it’s a newbie’s work you go very easy on him, because the first thing he needs is self-confidence, so you don’t point out every detail of what he did wrong, but tell him that he is on the right track, and you are happy that he is doing what he is doing. However if it’s not a newbie you tell him whatever you want to, he will take it, and he will know if you’re right, or not.
You kind of mixed it up as your post suggest that I criticised the 1500+ posts. No, I criticised the picture, but I was honest, since he had 1500+ posts, so I assumed he wasn’t a newbie, and I was expecting him to do better.