Is NSFW ok? Looking for opinions on topology

I can’t find rules for the forum. So before I post the full version, I am looking for opinions on ahem balls. I realize my motivation to learn 3d is powerd by NSFW content… so this just happens to be my first attempt at topology.

image

I’ll post full version, just wondering first if it’s acceptable on the forum.

Edit Full version:

retopo deez nutz.blend (177.2 KB)


Nudity is ok, but porn or extreme violence etc is not. Such posts need to be tagged with #nsfw which adds an automatic blur to images to protect accidental visitors and gallery viewers.

So, looking for opinions on the topology.

Tan (Left): More polys, seems to be easier to sculpt, edge flow is less predictable.
Pink (Right): Less polys, difficult to sculpt because of the patches on the sides, it is very difficult to make it perfectly round. But very nice edge flow I think.

So, the problem is that I don’t understand why the pink (right) version is so difficult to make round. I see the reflection of the edges undesirably and when trying to sculpt and smooth, that patch seems to become pointy.

Can the topology be improved further? Is there a best of both worlds here?

Edit: Oh, and this will be animated with rigging/bones and is for a game engine, so topology and optimization is important.