Problem making faces? Begginers Issue

Ive been tracing an image on Blender,
after completing my tracing and insuring that all the points are connected to each other by extruding point to point, then filling the gaps in between two final points, i attempt to select the points in an area to create an extrudable face. yet when i do this by selecting multiple points and then pressing enter to finalize my selection and then F to fill, all im getting is more points. Help anyone??

Could you explain more what you expect? From what I can ewe in the pictures it looks like expected behavior