I did some postwork in The GIMP to make it look old.
Very nice, but unfortunately not there yet.
It has some great 2D qualities, but the specular shaders on some materials make some objects 3D, unwanted.
But still, very nice scene.
I think it’s the best toon picture I’ve seen. Mickey’s nose should be a bit more smaller…
wooooow!! got only one crit: Turn down sme of the 3d shaders, looks too 3d… !! but i like it VERY much!!
oh, and u need some shadows under mickey… 
If you did what the others have suggested, and also made his ears slightly bigger (i’ll have to check on that one), it would look more like the original
Aligorith
I like it. Great interpretation of the original.
BgDM
Two thumbs up from me. OldskoolPunk, how did you model that? A mesh cube or a plane? You have to animate it now. Top marks from me.
Steamboat Willie! Oh I love that. One of my favorite cartoons. Wish I had thought of modelling that. Very nice.
Wow thanks for the posts everybody! I am still pretty new here I really appreciate it.
As for the “too 3D” thing , yes you are right. I was not going for the “flat” look, but I totally missed what I was trying to achive. (remember those old 3d viewfinders we had when we were little?)The reason for the lack of shadow under him was because I accidentally saved over the boat file, and had only a small rendered picture of it, so I pasted mickey and the background in right before the deadline!!
I will keep trying my next one will be better!
PS. This was my first finished works post, well my first 2 I posted 2 at same time.