My brother is a piper, and I have here a simplified model of the chanter, along with two reeds, all set on a tartan. I did the tartan using the cloth simulator, and then added a denim texture to help with the normal map.
I’m thinking I need to turn down the specularity a bit more on the reeds (it’s already at 0.300).
I redid the bottom of the chanter, creating a better low-poly bottom and subsurf’ing it. I also tried to get the material to look more like African blackwood: