Explosion experiments

Been experimenting with rendering explosions in blender
Feedback appreciated, trying to nail that houdini production look.

3 Likes

The simulations are very impressive!

I think I’m recognizing a shading problem that can happen with smoke. There seems to be a glowing outer shell outside the smoke. I don’t know how your material works, but that looks like an emission channel spilling outside the density. In a real explosion, the smoke particles are the thing that’s glowing, so the emission cannot float in mid air where there is no density. I have encountered this in my own smoke materials in the past and fixed it by using the density as a mask for the emission (simply, multiply the temperature, or whatever you are using for the emission, with the density).

subtle at high res but very true. Ill try that for the next iteration

1 Like

Very nice! Any chance for a video tutorial?

Thanks, yes I am working on tutorials. But it is a paid addon i develop, not blender’s mantaflow.

That’s fine. I will gladly learn any workflow.

1 Like

Does your solver support velocity pumps? In order to get really nice explosion behaviour you often have to pump additional velocity into the sim and have it either push or pull or add to the already existing velocity. This is what’s lacking in the second example - your smoke spikes go up and then they freeze because the source is no longer there (adding vel). In order to get proper realistic spikes you need to build these velocity pumps that push further than the source.

Pyro/fluid dynamic solvers have an intrinsic inertia that is not in line with physics - they react too slow. You have to build the violent exponential expansion into the sources and pumps or you wont be able to do a real looking detonation.

Yes it does. Second example i recreating something similar to this houdini tutorial: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=7Yb_SsppVYw

I actually used the same volumetric emitter setup. I agree my version loses momentum too much at the beginning