To those who have an experience with both Quadriflow and other remesher tools, such as Zbrush’s Zremesher, is Quadriflow just bad, or all the others have the same problems? By problems I mean, often fails to work completely, citing inconsistent normals or non-manifold as a reason, and even when it d…

You might wanna have alook at this… also comparing to other remesher… [image] Quad Remesher auto-retopologizer Released Scripts and Themes Quad Remesher — an auto-retopologizer from the developer of ZBrush ZRemesher — is available for Blender, following 3ds Max, Maya and …

This is just my personal opinion about Quad-Remesher: The result might look good, but in practice, there’re too many problems that the Quad-Remesher cannot solve. In particular, (and this happened me too many times), any crease in the mesh will have an incorrect polygon flow that jump from one side…

[image] Okidoki: You might wanna have alook at this… also comparing to other remesher… Yeah, can see the difference on screenshots already. May even mistake it for human created model in some cases. Versus Quadriflow’s degenerated shapes and twisted loops [image] Secrop: The result might…

If you want to avoid spirals, no automatic remesher will do. If you don’t care, it doesn’t matter too much which one you use, they’re all pretty good these days

[image] Secrop: The result might look good, but in practice, there’re too many problems that the Quad-Remesher cannot solve. In particular, (and this happened me too many times), any crease in the mesh will have an incorrect polygon flow that jump from one side to the other Yes, it’s not exac…

I could bear with some spirals, but Quadrflow takes them to next level. Making whole limbs twisted and wobbly, at random (may look nice on another side of the model) [image] Gyazo Gyazo is the easiest way to record screenshots & videos you can share instantly. Save time with async visual…

Yeah, that’s the consequence of automatic retopology. As I said, there’s no existing retopologizer that avoids spirals

[image] DeckardX08: Not to mention I had to use 100K target polycount to not lose fingers That is awful! :smile: Does the remesher have Instant Meshes built in? I’m pretty sure that it’s a lot better than QF.

[image] DeckardX08: Still looks better than using decimated Dyntopo I just use decimated dyntopo to make the mesh ‘lighter’ when I do the retopo manually. [image] Musashidan: if you don’t guide it by often manually tweaking verts or running global polish on unmasked areas around open bor…

[image] joseph: Yeah, that’s the consequence of automatic retopology. As I said, there’s no existing retopologizer that avoids spirals You’re right of course. In Zremesher you can limit this by remesh by polygroups, so there will always be a clean loop wherever you have a polygroup break.

How good is Quadriflow Remesh compared to other Auto-retopo solutions?

Support Modeling

Okidoki (Okidoki) September 3, 2024, 8:52am 2

You might wanna have alook at this… also comparing to other remesher…