Hi there.
Just a quick thought: I just had to download an update for LibreOffice, and after I’ve tested the normal download with sluggish results, I turned to the torrent, and it is so much faster.
That made me wonder if it would not be beneficial for Blender to be available through that path as well ?
I don’t have a clue about bandwidth and stuff like that for the Blender Foundation, but I guess it can be a good way to re-distribute the strain on the servers ?
I think about release days, when thousands of maniacs like myself jump on the latest version for their OS. Isn’t that a bit heavy at those moments?
I share NinthJake’s opinion, it’s a less-than-100MB-download, and there are several mirrors. Offering a torrent as an additional option for every release seems like superfluous work.
OK !
I thought it might be a good idea because of the strain on the servers, but i may well be completely wrong !
It’s only that in the case of LibreOffice (209MB), the regular down;oad was soooo sluggish compared to the torrent, that it seemed it could be translated to Blender.
As long as the BF depends on bandwidth donations from third parties, Blender can hardly be called “lightweight”.
The whole point of using torrents is to enable anyone, including those third parties, to donate bandwidth.
Are torrents superfluous work because there are mirrors? Let’s consider how the mirror system works:
People have to choose the “best” mirror manually. How do you know which one is the best? Answer: You try all of them, one after another. Or you pick the one you used last time. Or you pick download.blender.org and ignore the others because you don’t trust third parties unless there are checksums (MD5, SHA1 etc.) to verify the download against. I don’t see any checksums on the Blender website, do you?
Now let’s compare that with a BitTorrent-based distribution system:
You download a .torrent file straight from blender.org, preferably via https. This will make reasonably sure that the .torrent file is authentic. The .torrent file contains cryptographic hashes on each platform binary for a particular Blender release. You open the torrent and pick the binary you want to download. The BT client will connect to multiple seeders (i.e. mirrors) at once and verify each downloaded block against the hashes in the .torrent file. While your own download is in progress, others will download blocks from you, i.e. you become another mirror.
Bottom line: BitTorrent is not only faster (more mirrors!) and cheaper (for the BF) but more secure, too.
I think the reason why the BF maintains a 1990s-style distribution system is because most Blender users are on Windows, and Windows still doesn’t come with a BT client installed by default. Otherwise switching to BT would be a no-brainer.
@jpb06 : but that is down to the user, isn’t it ?
I mean, sorry if i go back to LibreOffice once more, but the torrent content is clear as source water, 100% legal stuff, and using the torrent proved to be much faster in my case. So anytime I’ll have to update LibreOffice, I know i will do it this way, and I am glad they give this option IN ADDITION to a regular download.
Is it adapted to Blender, being a very small Application ? It seems not.
However, for stuff like HD versions of previous shorts, it could be great. Are ED, BBB, Sintel or ToS downloadable from Blender.org, I don’t even know…
It’s not important anyway, just a random thought !
It seemed to me to fit rather well to the open-source mentality, having users helping in their own way.
I’ve been seeding LibreOffice for 24hours now, and more than 300MB went uploaded, so 1.5 times the size of the download.
You’ve been brainwashed. No one ever had their account blocked for legal use of BitTorrent. That’s a lawsuit the ISP would lose.
Some ISPs throttle BitTorrent to speed up other types of traffic, but that’s a matter of net neutrality, not piracy. They may as well throttle YouTube for the same reason.
BitTorrent is not adapted to files that expire quickly. For example, there wouldn’t be much benefit in distributing the daily BuildBot builds via BT.
However, for the bi-monthly stable release it is ideal. As I said before, the entire release folder could be bundled in one multi-file torrent. That’s a total payload of 600MB+. Each participant downloads and seeds only the files that they need.
It’s a shame that so many people have been taught to see BT only as a piracy tool. It’s a network protocol, nothing more.
On top of that, many Linux distributions are available via bittorrent as well(torrents being safer against corruption too!), so Blender would hardly be threading an untrodden path.
Gwenouille, you might want to consider proposing this on the IRC!
that’s a great idea, as you mentioned for official builds only. It’s a question of efficiency, it’s an excellent protocol and NOT a piracy tool. Don’t drink the kool-Aid (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drinking_the_Kool-Aid)
Well as a means of easing the strain on BF’s servers it is not a bad idea per say but other problems will surface from it. First of all when a new version of Blender get released the massive amounts of people who try to download the torrent will make it almost impossible for everyone to download it. The Blender Foundation will have to rent/buy a seedbox if they want to supply everyone with usable download speeds.
Then when the releases get so old that no-one seeds them anymore you won’t be able to download them via torrent anyway. Not to say that it is not worth a shot (however a seedbox will be expensive) but it might not be so usable as people may think.
when a new version of Blender get released the massive amounts of people who try to download the torrent will make it almost impossible for everyone to download it
Well, can’t that be said of a regular download too ?
Then when the releases get so old that no-one seeds them any more you won’t be able to download them via torrent anyway
But then you still can go to regular download… as we do now.
@fweeb: Oh yes, but i thought they were available there too. But i can’t find a link to the past projects… if someone knows where to find them !
Now I want to know what IRC is ? Is it this sort of channel for developpers ? I once installed a software called “pigeon” or something like that for that matter but it was a bit too obscure for me…
I personally don’t see the need for it. For starters, I’ve never had an issue with the download speeds for Blender from either blender.org or graphicall.org. I generally get blender from graphicall these days because most of the time, something new will pop up that’s still in the pipeline, and I want a taste of it.
The issue with bit torrent is that it’s great for popular stuff (i.e. current movies & tv shows), for more niche stuff though, torrents get stale after an initial release, so you go to find something and you’ve got 1 seeder and 3 leechers and a 3 day download for a less than 100 MB file.
Also, distribution via torrent means going to torrent sites that bombard you with pop ups and fake flash/java updates and other nasty stuff that makes my antivirus program balk. So, I’ll stick to graphicall.org for now. As far as security goes, I’ve never had any issues with blender’s mirrors or graphicall.org’s either, so I feel safe using them.
Personally, I think Blender has no issues with the way it’s distrubuted now, but on the other hand, if someone wants to make a torrent and seed it, there’s no one stopping them from doing so. You don’t need permission from anyone, including the blender foundation to redistribute the package as long as you follow the guidelines, so if you want to make it available that way, go for it. Who’s stopping you?
I don’t see much point in it. Like others already said, it’s just 40 something megabytes. In any case, I also don’t see why you can’t find a torrent file for every new version of it.
On the contrary, BitTorrent performs best with popular downloads. The more people join a torrent, the quicker the load on the initial seed will decrease to zero, because clients will download from each other instead. The total throughput of a busy torrent typically exceeds the capacity of the original seed by orders of magnitude. Which is why FTP is always slower (and more expensive).
Then when the releases get so old that no-one seeds them anymore you won’t be able to download them via torrent anyway. Not to say that it is not worth a shot (however a seedbox will be expensive) but it might not be so usable as people may think.
I’m not sure why you think a separate “seedbox” would be required. The BF’s regular FTP server can be configured to seed torrents, even from the same folder that is used for FTP. Also, with the BF acting as a fallback seed, older Blender torrents can stay online indefinitely at no cost.
Errrr… No one is stopping me doing anything John_L. Have you read the first post ?
“That made me wonder if it would not be beneficial for Blender to be available through that path as well ?”
That’s all. Asking if it would be a good move or not. I didn’t complain about anything or anyone, did I ?
Besides, I don’t see why you’d have to go to dangerous sites with nasty stuff… I am talking about the official Blender.org website providing the link.
Like here: http://www.libreoffice.org/download/libreoffice-fresh/
Nothing of the sort here. Just a link to the torrent file, and off you go.
You don’t seem to understand what this topic is about. We are not talking about distributing Blender through The Pirate Bay or something.
What’s stopping me? Nothing, except that only the Blender Foundation can publish an official Blender torrent. The suggestion is for them to publish such a torrent which can then be seeded by people like you and me, providing higher download speeds than FTP and at the same time taking load off the BF’s own servers, without compromising security.