If that can be helpfull, i like the second lighting, but i enjoy the reflection of the window in the first lighing the most.
Pretty sure it’s not helpfull at all.
First of all awesome ship! I gotta vote for the 2nd lighting. It shows off the detail much better. I would suggest playing with the lights and darks a bit to make the ship more of a focal point. Think of it this way, if you filtered the image into only grayscale, would the ship stand out from the ground very much? Maybe include light from molten lava from the force of the impact or smoke behind the ship to give it more of a silhouette. I hope that helps. Seriously great job texturing though!