Serious: Can topology and/or modeling techniques be copyrighted?

That is why I love the individual artist CG community, if we feel we might affect another person in a negative way, we almost always makes it a point to ask the person directly.

All these I have learn from being in this community, one of the most drama-less, “just talk it out” community in the world.

I couldn’t knock off the feeling that I might step on the individual’s idea regardless of how many people say you might not be able to copyright a topology or box modeling.

Though the course was 95% done ready to be published, I can’t sleep at night…I felt I am being a “bad guy”…so I move everything into a backup drive and will never touch it again.

Now I can sleep at night again.

I still don’t pretend to know whether topology is copyrightable or even box modeling is copyrightable…the fact that he did not reply “ok go ahead” is what eventually causes me to stop.

The negative side effect on me is, because of this “debacle”, I don’t even see myself ever using box modeling again for fear that I might accidentally used any of his modeling method…

Maybe someday I will be able to “resolve” this mental trauma.

Obviously, I have not looked at the tutorial you made, or the one it was trying to copy so I can not comment.

But I have had several times in my life that I had to understand copyright. As a songwriter and band member in the 1980s. In the 90’s and 2000s as a filmmaker/writer when I was certain people had taken ideas of mine that I could not prove, or that I had to understand the nature of what plagiarism was, and at least know enough if I should let it be or pursue it. I had a guy pretty much take a film festival name right out from under me without me realizing it. So I spent a few days in the Law Library looking up Trademark law and case history, just to see if I had a leg to stand on etc.

I have had ideas that I have had to find out enough about Patent law just to understand if it would qualify.

I am not a lawyer. But I feel as an artist you have to know more than just “have an opinion” about it. That the law is very complex and based on previous cases. Not even just the letter of the law. And people can break the spirit of the law, yet win because they had more money or acted faster or both. And there is nothing you can do about it.

Also people can draft contracts that contradict or even break the law, or by trying to enforce a contract or license, can actually break the law. So any contract or license can be found to not hold up to the scrutiny of either the letter or the intent of the law.

So as an artist, to navigate your career in whatever you do, it is a must that you study the source material of the law (which I have) and also study cases (which I have) to understand the implications and various complexities.

This is not to try and win anything or prove anything. And lord knows not to win arguments. But to navigate your career and know were you stand.

So in your case it could be one of two things. Either you are infringing on another original (even if educational) work, which by law can have a copyright, or you are sufficiently uneducated in the area of copyright that you don’t know if you are or not.

The solution to both, is not to follow advice here, but to look it up yourself. Both the letter of the law, and some case law. And also visit websites of lawyers who often write free articles as a sort of marketing angle to get new business. And in these articles you can find a lot of good information.

Only then can you make your own sound and logical decision.

Knowledge is power.

1 Like

Fun topic to read. As a CAD designer in the architectural world, this topic gets brought up a lot in our industry with I.P.

I do not like a rigid approach to I.P. and copyrights. I think design communities shouldn’t stifle creativity but embrace it. There is certainly room for copyrights and there does need to be a line drawn in the sand. I believe it needs to stay reasonable though. I.P. and copyright gets unreasonable quickly these days.

A good self-made documentary found on Youtube is “Everything’s A Remix” by Kirby Ferguson and is a good watch that resonates with this topic.

-TZ

2 Likes

HAH! I knew it was Joe Alter. :nerd_face:

I wish NewTek hadn’t pissed him off so much.

1 Like

Well it is something they are good at. At least at the end of the day maybe they can sleep well at night knowing that at least there is something they do well in LightWave land. Alienate, piss people off and generally make a complete muck of things. Often it seems without even trying very hard. In fact. I think doing nothing and not trying at all seems to be their comfort zone. LightWave RIP.

I did not know you harbor such thought on Jimmy Neutron Lightwave !
I don’t know how to use LightWave, but I will always like it from a distance because it made Jimmy Neutron ;p

Oh, I never said I have any hate on LightWave. Actually it was the first 3D tool I ever used and have fond memories of it. I have also used it off and on up til most recently. It has a lot of cool features, and even the newest version ads other coolness. LightWave is a great app in a lot of ways.

NewTek on the other hand was never originally a 3D company. They were started as a video company. And they had also hosted - if you will - LightWave and the LightWave development team. This was a completely different team. Eventually they had a falling out, and that team left and became Modo.

LightWave was left with NewTek to manage and over 20 years mismanaged it into the ground.

Hence, my comments, about NewTek. Not LightWave.

So did you learn Modo to get back the nostal ?

Well, it is a long story. But in short no. Like Modo though. Just bad timing and it never worked out to fit it into the pipeline.

1 Like