Star Trek vs. Star Wars. who would win?

If the empire sent death stars againsd the federation’s puny ships they would win, unless they find the exhaust vents.
Anyway, star wars would choke star trek to a thin pencil the width of a quark. Okay maybe just the width of a pencil.

There is no point arguing about the ships’ power, as they are all relative.

I spent 15 minutes on that analysis…

people seam to forget about the abrasive armor. 5 Borg cubes spent 5 min. hacking away at it and it still didnt give, so there is no way a star destroyer could even dent it.

Armor being deployed
http://www.startrek.com/imageuploads/200303/voy-272-voyager-s-new-futurist/320x240.jpg

I’m embarrassed for all of you.

:stuck_out_tongue:

Ohhh you’re sooooooooo funny…

My sides are aching…

neither, they would kill eachother

This thread is very sad. :frowning:

WOW LOOK AT ME.

I’m a big obnoxious kid who’s boosting his ego by making fun of other people trying to seriously participate in this thread. YAAAAAY!

I’m soooooo funny.

:expressionless:

Whore it up, guys.

Yes, it does sound like you as a matter of fact. %|

Yes, it does sound like you as a matter of fact. %|[/quote]

But I wasn’t talking about myself was I?
No, no matter how unintentionally relevant, the point still stands. Diverting it to doesn’t make either one of us less of an asshole.

Wow. Calm yourself, Valarking. %|

As far as I can tell, nobody was seriously making fun of this thread. It’s all lighthearted, although I sincerely apologize if I honestly offended anyone by my harmless (or at least I thought it was harmless) comment.

Let’s try to exercise a little self-control. I see no need to lash out on anyone here. :slight_smile:

WB, i hope some borg come and assimilate you.

:stuck_out_tongue:

i like your story HOSJ! but you need a part where Jar gets tortured to death. the sad thing is, he wouldnt even know hes being tortured. now, are there any morons THAT big in star trek(besides the obvious)?
:smiley:

Here some comparisons with trek and wars. Some pictures on the same search results and same type of transport, weapons, armor and such.

Star Wars
Impresive armor, dude :slight_smile:
http://www.aoqz76.dsl.pipex.com/Web%20Page%20Components/Wallpaper/Movies/Star%20Wars%20Clone%20Wars.jpg
http://iml.jou.ufl.edu/Newszine/staff/Homepages/Summer99/Burdette/images/troopers.jpg
And here a nice gun, looks heavy weaponary.
http://www.realistictoyguns.com/images3/heavy_blaster02.jpg

Star Trek
THis armor is defently invunerable.
http://images.google.nl/imgres?imgurl=http://tsu_campus.tripod.com/QtheImmortal/Kimpromo2.jpg&imgrefurl=http://tsu_campus.tripod.com/QtheImmortal/photos2.html&h=250&w=167&sz=6&tbnid=bE0Ge-p_tm8J:&tbnh=105&tbnw=70&start=16&prev=/images%3Fq%3Dstar%2Btrek%2Bsoldier%26hl%3Dnl%26lr%3D%26client%3Dfirefox-a%26rls%3Dorg.mozilla:nl-NL:official%26sa%3DG
Here the there heavy weaponary.
http://www.collectoybles.com.au/catalog/images/mrphaser.jpg

Star Trek, Star Wars space ship comparison.

The star trek ships ofthen have a few laser thingies, 2 torpedo launchers.
The Star Wars ships are maybe very slow, but have on each 100 meter a huge laser cannon, beamlaunchers and impressive shields for each section. They can even split some space ships in parts durning a battle.

wars vs trek transport.
Full of lasers, shield, and high speed energy engine up to 50 times the spedd of light.
http://www.starwars.jp/machine/image/outrider.jpg
Mmhh impressive.
http://scifi3d.theforce.net/downloads/Star_Trek/9_Root/large_shuttle6.jpg

Important update to my essay. Page 3.

It is honestly useless to debate about the ships’ power, as we can only compare them to ships in their own respective universes. Noobs.

Has everyone looked at the rest of that guy’s site?
Friggin’ Hilarious…
Particularly the book of ratings

Umm… sorry for the o/t…
I don’t really know enough about star trek to warrant commenting on the topic (yes that’s right, a computer nerd who knows little more than the fact that there’s a guy called “Kirk” and another called “Picard” and they’re different people…)

All I can say is that I saw SW Episode 4 on TV recently and in it at the end Vader and two storm troopers in tie fighters took out squad after squad of X-Wings, but in ST the Enterprise can take volley after volley of pumelling without a scratch, save some control panels exploding. Does this mean that TIE fighters are many many times stronger than whatever attacks the Enterprise in any given show?

The trialers for SW #3 are out: high-rez and low

Looks pretty impressive!

Robot would just cut them all up into pieces after saying “DANGER! there be geeks in the hizzaaa” because friggin’ robots rule.

http://www.b9robotresource.com/images/FV2004/fv2004-small/markandb9_small.jpg

Or maybe star destroyers are more powerful then borg cubes.

ok size comparison.
Imperial class star destroyer: 1606m
Nebulan-B frigate: 300m
Standard Borg cube: 3040m
Sovereign class (ex. USS Enterprise 1701-e): 685m
intrepid class (ex. USS Voyager): 344m
Galaxy class (ex USS Enterprise 1701-D): 642m
Dominion planetary assult ship: 4500m
Borg tactical cube: 1500m