Which shading looks right to you?

Which shading looks right to you? Top or bottom?

It’s just a very simple cube on a very simple plane with same basic materials, lit with an interior HDR.

Scene (just for context understanding):


for me, in this context, the bottom of the two cubes… more top face definition, whereas the upper cube’s top face vanishes into the background.

that said, not sure this means anything in the final render, especially since the cube is not at the same angle, and mebbe that top face shadow will interfere with something else. >shrugs<

3 Likes

By 99% they look identical, except the optical illusion as KDLynch said.