Will AI Replace Animators?

This has been a burning question for a lot of my fellow animators, comments on my videos and students in our private community, so I thought I’d address the topic and give my two cents from a professional animator’s perspective, studio lead and someone who has connections to artist working behind the scenes of big productions.

AI tools are changing animation and the industry but not the way most people think. If you’ve been anxious about your animation career or pursuing animation in school, this is for you.
In this video, I break down what’s actually happening right now, what’s coming in the next 5 years, and how animators can stay ahead of the curve, and not get replaced by a clanker.

the term clanker has been used as a slur against people with prosthetics, might be better to not use that word.

In what country? Have literally never heard that.

4 Likes

no idea about the country, english spoken Tiktok.
and some Foss moderated spaces have disallowed usage of the word.

Perhaps not having a tiktok account factors into why I’ve never heard it…

6 Likes

Well, it’s also used as a slur against those silly separatist droids during Clone Wars, so seem to be very appropriate considering the context :slightly_smiling_face:

5 Likes

indeed, best judgement is a thing.thanks for reminding me! :smiley:

Anything can be found insulting if you try hard enough.

5 Likes

This might be controversial here, but my thought is that AI will in fact replace most animation at some point.

Animation will still exist as a hobby in the same way painting does. But the painting of portraits as a mass produced service has been mostly ended by photography and It will very much be the same here. Animation as an art will keep existing, but AI will take over the more commercial, mass produced aspects of animation.

AI doesn’t even need to take the jobs directly for it to happen. Even if an animation studio decides not to use it, it will get out-competed by those that do or even single individuals.

I think AI is a case of “the genie is out of the bottle”. For better or worse, it’s there to stay (open source AIs are always just a few months behind the state of the art, so it couldn’t possibly disappear). It’s also nowhere close to its maximum potential and is still steadily improving. You can argue current AI isn’t good enough to replace animation, but future AI in a few years almost certainly will (remember that just 3 years ago, it could barely make coherent still images).

I see lots of artists say that AI content is always bad, often focusing on the flaws to dismiss it. But I see that as coping and putting your head in the sand, because lots of AI content is actually not bad and the flaws are getting solved one after the other (these days, you don’t see nearly as many flawed hands anymore).

–

An other point I would like to bring: if AI can take my job, it will also be able to take a lot of other jobs very shortly after. If that happens, it will change the world to the point the very concepts of jobs and the economy will have to be redefined, and it won’t be my problem to face alone.

The worst case scenario for us might be for AI to get just barely good enough to make artists jobless and then stop improving there, never fulfilling the rest of its promise.

In any case, I will likely keep doing art, because I enjoy it. Before AI, there were already artists who were better than me, nothing has changed there as long as I don’t need to make a living out of it.

4 Likes

You know, I would say the same about human animation.
I just watched the Bad Guys 2, and I feel like [good] modern animation is pretty much defined by creative choices and hand-crafted effects, rather then rendering or simulation technology as it was through, say, the earlier era of 3D. It’s the conscious decisions to juggle between 2d and 3d, realism and stylization, complexity and simplicity, for the sake of the effective storytelling. It’s about exercising control over everything. The same reasons we don’t see pure mocap displacing animation, I suppose.
Because so many of these decisions are only made in the context of the particular character/scene/mood/style, it wouldn’t make sense to have a predictive model trying to figure it out :person_shrugging:

If anything, I’m now inclined to think that misuse of AI gives us a better perspective on what creativity is and what is really important in art, and why current AI efforts are a dead end. Intelligent design - something that current implementation is simply not capable of due to how they work.

That’s said, of course, the industry will suffer, but not because AI is good for that sort of thing, but because some people would see the world burn if it brings them money :unamused:

7 Likes

Indeed, but the quality of animation also doesn’t really matter for if it gets replaced or not. AI images are not a direct replacement for animation, they are a new separate medium and they can compete with animation without being animation, by changing the entire ecosystem.

AI has a different advantage, which is its speed and low barrier of entry. If anything, making animation even fancier makes it even more vulnerable to being replaced in mass production settings for this very reason. but it could simultaneously earn animation a more artistic role, allowing it to survive, just for a different purpose than it used to have.

Ironically, if AI becomes good enough that it could earn its owners money, it probably won’t (or at least it will not last). It would be truly smart by that point and wouldn’t need the studio at all. It would bypass every current structure and would slip right out of the grasp of those who hoped to profit from it. The public has access to AI models that are close to the state of the art, so if AI can make actual quality content, it will be everywhere instantly and there won’t be profit.

4 Likes

You have interesting points and I see many people with a similar opinion.
I tend to think that it’s not going to be a black or white thing.
It’s not always about doing things cheaper, I mean things are always easier to do but overall budgets of movie doesn’t change a lot, I think it’s the contrary !

If AI is cheap and easy to use that mean that everyone can do it therefore a producer doesn’t have a value added to their products that make them stand over the others.

I think at some point AI will just raise the overall level and force people to be even more creative to stand out of it…

Also I think AI as an art tool is very similar to a programming tool : yes you can write pieces of code and small addons, but it’s very limited if you’re not a programmer yourself. You can ask AI to write a movie script but if you don’t know how to fix the narrative structure or bend it to your own set of constraints it’s never going to be good. And if you know all there is to know about story writing why not write the story yourself, it’s going to be way less confusing. But you can always use AI to pitch you some ideas or to help with smaller parts of your work.

I think it’s basically the same for concept art, or everything creative that AI can produce.

Just as said in the video , if you work in a studio you know how much constraints you need to account for and how picky people can be when it comes to iterations. At some point there is a lot of various constraints that I’m not sure AI can effectively replace a team of artists. But In the meantime it’s clear that it will offer a lot of new tools and possibilities, it’s already used to create cheap content for advertising video games or else …
It’s likely that being an artists in a few years is going to be harder than a few years ago, but I’d be very surprised if artists end up being completely replaced… If that happend I’ll probably do my personal projects with blender and I’ll try to monetize them somehow :smiley:

5 Likes

Maybe some animators need to be replaced. :smiley: If you think about it, animation is sort of communication. It’s supposed to be story telling. AI can tell stories, but it has a huge disadvantage, because it does not live a human life and does not interact with the physical world, so maybe if it can replace an animator, that’s not so bad. I think the ones AI cannot replace are the important ones anyway. Maybe some competition is not so bad. A lot of movies are basically the same stories retold over and over again and again and AI can do that, so maybe in the longer run it will push human made movies and animations to concentrate more on being original and new and more based on authentic human experience.

That’s what I think as well.

6 Likes

Good point about AI forcing higher quality, I hadn’t thought about it that way.

As to whether AI can replace humans in the future (not just for art, but also lots of other jobs), I would say it depends on how it will develop.

  • One thing that’s pretty important is where the limit on intelligence is. If AI manages to become smarter than humans, it’s really hard to predict what will happen next.

  • If AI gains a long term memory and the ability to physically live in the real world with robots, it could end up having more human-like experiences, which could make it much better at writing stories.

  • If AI gets smart enough to improve itself, even just barely at first, things could get crazy really fast. But at that point, the question stops being “will AI replace animation?” and more “how do we navigate a completely new alien world with no historical precedent?”.

5 Likes

Well, at some point I tend to apply a “let’s see when we get there” approach to those kind of questions, there are so many ways anything can go south…
For instance I’m quite confident in humanity being able to nearly eradicate itself on it’s own…
Or, if AI manage to gain consciousness why it would conform to humanity ? Maybe AI stories for AI would make no sense to us… and we’ll get back to our human entertainment at last…

Also we already managed to make an alien world to people living 100 years ago but we adapted to that in a completely natural way…
Like we’re having a conversation in a real time fashion from many different places in the world while watching reality TV show on youtube and playing videogame, ordering food on our smartphones, finding our ways with our GPS thanks to all the satellites we put in orbit… How people of our age a century ago would think about that and how mundane all that is to us ?

2 Likes

The way things are going, it looks like we will end up with multiple AIs, not a single central monster like in sci-fi. It could be hard to say what AI will be like, because it’s likely we will see many different ways at the same time.

I am cautiously optimistic about AI (outside of it taking my job). I see lots of potential for it to accelerate scientific research and help us solve some of our biggest problems.

It could plausibly be the case that humanity is more likely to destroy itself without AI and it ends up saving us from ourselves. Movies just prefer the drama of using AI as a villain so that’s the default scenario in stories.

Now, it remains to be seen if we can adapt to the same degree of change happening multiple times faster, because progress is likely to go that fast in the scenario I describe. I imagine lots of people wouldn’t be able to follow and I’m not sure what kind of chaos it could cause.

3 Likes

Raise your hand if you think LLM’s can actually think.
Now, if you raised your hand: Stop typing. Stop getting into discussions online. Start reading about what LLM’s actually are.

6 Likes

AI feeds on what is created.
At the moment, some humans use their creativeness to stand out of it ; the simple fact to publish, distribute their creative work, means that it will be sampled by AI.
AI will be trained to copy it, illegally or in a place on Earth, that will not respect laws about your consent.
You will work months, years to produce something original, using your mastering of techniques. And that could be copied in weeks.

There is a disproportion of time scales, that transfers benefits of your creative work to benefit of owner of AI.

That is a job.

Writer and producer. Other jobs.

Like members of a team.

That is what you are proposing to use it for.

At the end, we are not employing humans in fields that are interesting, stimulating them.
We are asking them to restrain their playground to what machines can’t do.
If we consider imagination of humans as infinite, we have to consider imagination of humans to build machines as infinite.
Theoretically, AI madness could end up to allow only one job : click worker to reinforce it.
Managers, already thinking as robots, will easily be replaced by some.
Politicians able to sacrifice lives to obtain flattering ciphers, too.

But in few years, oil production will inevitably decrease ; and an energy crisis will crash our current world. We are already struggling to produce weapons, ammunitions, at the pace, we are using them.
We will probably return faster to a world with less electronic devices, controlling less productions, than AI owners would need to take over the world.
The idea of technological progress will inevitably encounter a political backlash.

2 Likes

Well, no-one has ever lived in a world they fully understand by far… That doesn’t prevent people from enjoying their lives. TBH the nightmare scenario you’re describing to me we are already living it… But we manage to cope with it to some extent and I expect the same… Even if obviously it’s very unclear at an individual level rather than at the humanity level…

Now I tend to be more worried about the ecologicial, economical and political situation we’re currently living than the impact of AI on our societies… At least AI could bring positive outcomes :slight_smile:

@zeauro I’m not sure to completely understand your point and I’m not sure what I was saying earlier was clear enough too. I can try to elaborate further but it’s also hard to see that discussion evolving in something useful.

Anyway, here is what I think about creativity :
There is already centuries of good creative work examples. We can already rip off thousands of books, movies , pictures that are awesome. But it’s not that simple to make something good isn’t it ? …
What makes a good story that you’ll find compelling to read or watch ?
I’d say for sure the person writing it probably studied and enjoyed a lot of previous stories written by others just like AI. But we know that in many good stories there is also their human experience that is fed into it. Many masterpieces are born from the catharsis of the author’s life… How can you truly write something about love or violence if you haven’t experienced those in the first place ? Then there is also how good you are at telling stories. Some people live amazing life experience and when they talk about it it’s kind of boring… Some people can just talk about their last trip to the grocery store and it’s fascinating…
So yeah an AI can study stories and life experience of others to a point where it’s able to mimic a byproduct of it, but I’m very skeptical it’s possible to deeply inspire us as it will never be inspired in the first place… But… that’s just my opinion. Sometimes I ask chatGPT about life stuff and I got interesting answers so maybe I’m wrong…

1 Like

I don’t see it as a nightmare scenario, I would be able to adapt and even have much to gain myself. I’m more worried the changes happen too slowly and I end up stuck jobless because AI took only the art jobs and did nothing else.

Agreed, I see what humans are already doing as the greater threat.

One issue that happens with AI is that it develops a recognizable style in its writing or images. People start to be able to identify AI content because of it and it takes them out of it. This is pretty ironic, because human artists get praised when they develop a recognizable style.