Help, Strange reflections on metallic material 2.8

Support Lighting and Rendering
1

I’m trying to get realistic metal material, however the reflections seem incorrect. I am not sure if this a problem with blender or my settings.

Metal%20reflection%20render%20problem
Metal%20reflection%20render%20problem1280×949 747 KB

metal%20reflection%20render%20problem%20hdr
metal%20reflection%20render%20problem%20hdr1280×949 1020 KB

Looks better with hdri but still the black reflection looks off.

evvee%20metal%20render%20reflection%20problem
evvee%20metal%20render%20reflection%20problem1280×949 501 KB

Eevee looks better but still not satisfactory.

Recent post by another member on the forum having a similar problem.

@ [Comradebunny]
Eevee Metalic Material Reflections thread

Render settings for cycles default and enabled space screen reflections for eevee. Is this how the renderer is supposed to work and what are the solutions?

2

Can you post the .blend file?

3

Ring of Sauron.blend (905.2 KB)

4

You are seeing the reflection of the inside of the ring there, which is itself a reflection of other things.